You may only need three. Here are some suggestions:

SO much more than a liner! mark Keep It Going Longwear Eyeliner & Shadow. Reg. $11.00. Shade: Entourage 796695. With new shades: paradiso & naturalist! An innovative, multiuse eye color that just doesn’t give up! Each compact features two waterproof, gel-based shades that are buildable for extra intensity and literally last all day. 0.04 oz. net wt.

A brush with Greatness! mark Flat Eyeliner Brush. Item # 951523. Reg. $7.00. 6″ L
WHAT IT’S FOR: “Drawing a precise line on the eyelid, as well as smudging liners and shadows.”
HOW IT’S USED: “Dip brush in dark shadow, then run it along the lash line for a diffused, smoky look.” 

Get the look! mark No Place to Run Longwear Eyeliner. Reg. $9.00. Shade: Jet Set 675529. You won’t be able to hide your love of this liner-it sets in a minute, is waterproof and literally lasts all day. A cap ensures this smudge-resistant pencil won’t even run inside your makeup bag. 0.04 oz. net wt.